Hotels in Shelter Island, New York

Search & Compare Shelter Island Hotels

Get Secret Prices on select hotels

These prices aren’t available to everyone.

Pay now or later on most rooms

Free cancellation on most rooms

Price Guarantee

Best hotels in Shelter Island

With hotels.com we help you find the best hotels in Shelter Island, New York.

You can compare all of our Shelter Island hotel rooms including the major Shelter Island hotel chains using our genuine Hotels.com guest reviews as well as TripAdvisor Shelter Island hotel reviews to help find the perfect hotel room when booking your accommodation in Shelter Island. We also feature Expedia Shelter Island hotels and reviews.

When you book your Shelter Island stay with Hotels.com you may also earn free nights on participating hotels by joining the Hotels.com Welcome Rewards program. It's free to join and only takes 2 minutes to sign up and when you stay 10 nights you receive 1 night free*. So even a short weekend break in Shelter Island can get you on your way to a free night.

Why use Hotels.com to book your Shelter Island lodging & accommodation?

We can help you to find the perfect Shelter Island hotel room for almost any occaision. With our fast and secure hotel search you may compare different Shelter Island hotels by:

  • - Price
  • - Location within Shelter Island
  • - Neighborhoods in Shelter Island
  • - Nearby Shelter Island attractions
  • - Hotels in different areas of New York
  • - Genuine Hotels.com guest reviews for Shelter Island
  • - Star rating
  • - Amenities
  • - Hotel name & chain
  • - Theme


For every hotel in Shelter Island New York we provide:

  • - Up to the minute hotel rates & availability
  • - In depth hotel information and photos
  • - Detailed Shelter Island maps showing the locations of your hotel in Shelter Island and the nearest transport and landmarks
  • - TripAdvisor Shelter Island hotel review score


And when you make a hotel reservation in Shelter Island with Hotels.com we'll send you email and text confirmations with the reservation details of your Shelter Island hotel booking along with contact details, directions, information on nearby Shelter Island attractions, restaurants and even the weather - and if you get stuck, we're only a phone call away.

To make the most of our service, download our mobile & tablet apps and sign up to our newsletter or follow us on Facebook, Google+ or Twitter to receive the latest deals and Hotels.com Shelter Island discount codes.