The “fabulous” rating is well-deserved. The property is in a prime location, in a historical building, the room I stayed in was beautiful (I was upgraded), with preserved beams and stones from the original building, the linens were of good quality, the bathroom seemed newly done and well-built, the lighting, layout and decor of the room were well-designed. The room overlooked the Sorbonne, and the windows could be opened. The Wednesday afternoon concierge who checked me in greeted me warmly and was on point and amazing in all respects, and the staff I came across were all very nice. The Thursday concierge who checked me out was the only negative experience. I highly recommend.